Metaphysics of Perspective

Semantically important gestures and objects, as a rule, are presented in close-up shots, a departure from the laws of linear perspective. This may be seen in the Archangel Gabriel’s gesture of blessing in icons of the Annunciation, or images of the scroll St John of Damascus holds in medieval Russian O Tebe raduyetsya [In You Rejoices] icons, with the opening words of the hymn in honour of the Mother of God. This emphasis shows that the text of the song composed by St John of Damascus was at the very heart of the icon’s composition. The same may be said of depictions of the outer clothing (the "mantle") which the prophet Elijah leaves to his disciple Elisha on icons of the Ognennoye vozneseniye Ilyi Proroka [Fiery Ascent of the Prophet Elijah]. The materiality and the miraculous power of the "mantle" turns it into the central device of the composition, uniting heaven and earth.

The Fiery Ascent of the Prophet Elijah (sixteenth century), tempera on wood, 124 x 107 cm. State Historical Museum, Moscow.

Florenskii also linked the absence of shadows in the artistic space of the icon with the system of reverse perspective: "The absence of a definite focus of light, the contradictory nature of illumination in different places of the icon, the effort to bring forward masses which should have been overshadowed–yet again, this is neither coincidence nor a blunder by a naive craftsman, but artistic calculation, which imparts maximum artistic expressiveness."  Florenskii clearly follows Plato and his symbol of the Cave in the determination of people’s knowledge, since, in his works, light and shade acquire gnoseological meaning in the context of the metaphysics of reverse perspective. Platonic Ideas are "shadows," "the negative of things," "intaglio experiences;" a turn towards the light is a transition to a new level of cognition, and symbolizes our drawing closer to the truth. From any viewpoint, therefore, iconic images exclude shadow; when perceiving inscriptions, figures, architecture and landscape depicted on the icon, a turn (which also suggests a mobile gaze) may well convey gnoseological meaning. The icon is a transfigured reality, which knows no shadow. 

Novgorod School, The Raising of Lazarus (c. 1497), tempera on wood, 71.5 x 58 cm. State Russian Museum, St Petersburg.

—Oleg Tarasov, How Divine Images Became Art, 2024